Underemployed with a Degree: Resume Strategy for Overqualified Graduates

You have a college degree. You're working at a coffee shop. Or retail. Or an administrative job that requires a high school diploma.

You're not alone. According to the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, 41.8% of recent college graduates are underemployed, meaning they work in jobs that don't require a bachelor's degree.

That's nearly half of all new graduates stuck in positions below their qualifications.

This situation creates a specific resume challenge: how do you get hired for degree-required positions when your recent experience doesn't demonstrate degree-level work? And equally important: how do you avoid being screened out of appropriate jobs because you look "overqualified"?

The Two-Front Challenge

Underemployed graduates face rejection from both directions:

Rejected as "Underqualified"

When you apply for degree-appropriate jobs, your recent experience might not demonstrate relevant skills. The hiring manager sees:

• Education: B.A. Marketing, State University
• Experience: Barista, Coffee Chain, 2024-Present

The gap between credential and recent work raises questions. "What happened? Why aren't they using their degree?"

Rejected as "Overqualified"

When you apply for better positions than your current one, employers sometimes assume you'll:

• Leave as soon as something better comes along
• Be bored and disengaged
• Expect more money than the role pays
• Resist authority from less-credentialed managers

"Overqualified" rejections are particularly frustrating because you're being penalized for capability.

Strategy 1: Bridge the Gap on Your Resume

Your resume needs to demonstrate that your current work, despite its title, involves transferable skills.

Reframe Your Current Role

Every job involves skills that transfer. Extract them explicitly.

Before (minimal):

Barista, Coffee Chain, 2024-Present

• Made coffee drinks according to customer specifications
• Operated cash register and processed payments
• Maintained clean workspace

After (strategic):

Barista, Coffee Chain, 2024-Present

• Delivered 300+ customer interactions daily, maintaining 98% satisfaction rating during peak hours
• Trained 8 new team members on POS systems, customer service protocols, and inventory management
• Optimized opening procedures, reducing setup time by 15 minutes per shift
• Managed product displays and promotional materials, contributing to 12% increase in seasonal sales

Same job. Different framing. The second version demonstrates customer service, training, process improvement, and marketing sensitivity.

Connect Skills to Target Roles

Map your current work to your target career explicitly.

If you're targeting marketing roles:

"Experience serving diverse customer base provides direct insight into consumer preferences and behavior patterns"

If you're targeting management roles:

"Proven ability to train and mentor new team members while maintaining operational excellence under high-volume conditions"

If you're targeting client-facing roles:

"Daily management of 300+ customer interactions requiring rapid problem-solving and service recovery"

Highlight Non-Work Credentials

Your resume isn't limited to paid employment. Include:

Volunteer work: Marketing for a nonprofit. Event planning for a community organization. Anything that demonstrates skills your job doesn't.

Freelance or side projects: Built a website. Managed social media for a small business. Wrote content for pay. Even small gigs add credibility.

Certifications and courses: Google Analytics certification. HubSpot Academy courses. LinkedIn Learning completions. Show you're developing skills relevant to target roles.

Academic projects: If recent, include substantial class projects that demonstrate relevant work. Marketing campaigns developed. Business analyses conducted. Research completed.

Strategy 2: Apply to Roles Where Your Position Makes Sense

Not every role will understand your situation. Target employers where it makes sense.

Growing Companies

Startups and rapidly scaling companies hire for potential more than pedigree. They care about what you can do, not whether your work history follows traditional patterns.

Smaller Companies

Organizations with 20-100 employees often lack rigid HR screening. The hiring manager evaluates candidates directly rather than filtering through requirements checklists.

Companies Known for Alternative Hiring

Some employers explicitly value non-traditional paths. Research companies that advertise skills-based hiring or mention diverse backgrounds in job postings.

Entry Points That Accept Varied Backgrounds

Certain roles traditionally accept diverse experience:

• Sales development (results orientation valued over background)
• Customer success (service experience directly relevant)
• Recruiting (many recruiters come from varied backgrounds)
• Project coordination (organization skills from any context apply)
• Operations (reliability and process orientation matter more than specific experience)

Strategy 3: Address Overqualification Directly

When overqualification is the barrier, address it proactively.

In Your Cover Letter

"While my educational background might suggest I'm overqualified, I'm specifically seeking this role because [genuine reason]. I'm committed to contributing fully at this level and growing within your organization."

Genuine reasons might include:

• Interest in the industry
• Attraction to company mission
• Geographic preference
• Desire for specific work type over title
• Career pivot that makes the role strategically valuable

In Your Resume Summary

Marketing graduate seeking Customer Success Associate role to apply communication and problem-solving skills in a client-facing capacity. Committed to building a career in SaaS starting from foundational positions.

This signals awareness of the potential mismatch and frames your interest positively.

In Interviews

When they ask (and they might): "You have a degree in X. Why are you interested in this role?"

"I want to build a career in this industry, and I understand that means starting in roles where I can learn the business and prove my value. This position offers exactly that opportunity. My goal is to contribute fully here and grow within the company."

Demonstrate that you've thought about it, you're not desperate or confused, and you're genuinely interested.

Strategy 4: Consider Hiding Your Degree (Sometimes)

This is controversial but sometimes practical.

When to Consider It

If you're applying for roles that don't require degrees and your applications keep getting rejected, your degree might be triggering "overqualified" screening.

Some candidates have successfully applied for appropriate roles by:

• Omitting education from initial applications
• Listing only relevant certifications
• Disclosing education only after getting interviews

When NOT to Do This

• If the role requires a degree
• If you'd need to lie when asked directly
• If background checks will surface it anyway
• If you're uncomfortable with the approach

The Gray Area

You're not obligated to list everything on your resume. Omitting information isn't the same as lying. But if asked directly, you must answer honestly.

Some candidates take the approach: "My resume focuses on relevant experience. Education details available upon request."

This is a personal decision. Consider your comfort level and specific circumstances.

Strategy 5: Build While You Work

Your current job funds your life. Your side activities build your career.

Freelance in Your Target Field

Use platforms like Upwork, Fiverr, or industry-specific marketplaces to do paid work in your target field. Even small projects create:

• Real experience to add to your resume
• Portfolio pieces demonstrating capability
• Client testimonials and references
• Proof that someone paid you for target-field work

Create Your Own Projects

If freelance work isn't available:

• Build a marketing campaign for a hypothetical product
• Analyze data and publish findings
• Create a portfolio website
• Write articles in your field
• Develop a presence demonstrating expertise

Volunteer Strategically

Nonprofits need marketing, operations, finance, and technology help. Offer skills in exchange for experience and references.

The Mental Game

Underemployment is psychologically difficult. Managing your mindset helps.

Your Current Job Is Not Your Identity

You are not "a barista with a marketing degree." You are a marketing professional currently funding their career transition through service work. Frame it that way internally.

Comparison Is Destructive

Your college classmate who landed a corporate job immediately is not proof you failed. Different circumstances, different timing, different luck. Your path isn't linear, and that's increasingly common.

Take Progress Seriously

Every freelance gig, every certification, every networking conversation moves you forward. Progress that doesn't result in immediate job offers is still progress.

Set Time Boundaries

Don't let job searching consume all your non-work time. Dedicate specific hours to career building and then live your life. Constant searching without boundaries leads to burnout.

Talking About Your Situation

Networking is harder when your current role doesn't match your aspirations. Handle it directly.

The Conversation Approach

When someone asks what you do:

"I'm working in [current role] right now while building toward a career in [target field]. I'm actively developing skills through [what you're doing] and looking for opportunities in [specific target]."

This positions you as intentional rather than stuck. You have a plan, not just a problem.

Asking for Help

Be specific about what you're looking for:

"I'm targeting [specific role types] at [types of companies]. If you know anyone in those areas who might be open to a conversation, I'd really appreciate an introduction."

Clear asks generate better results than general "let me know if you hear of anything."

Timeline Expectations

Escaping underemployment often takes longer than initial job search. Realistic expectations prevent discouragement.

0-6 months: Build skills and experience through side projects, volunteering, freelancing 6-12 months: Apply strategically with enhanced resume, targeting appropriate employers 12-18 months: Combination of improved credentials and expanded network typically yields results

Some move faster. Some take longer. The key is consistent progress, not arbitrary timelines.

When to Consider Different Paths

If you've been underemployed for 2+ years despite consistent effort, consider:

Different career direction: Your degree field may have limited opportunity. Adjacent fields might offer better paths.

Additional credentials: Sometimes a certification or boot camp provides the specific skill that unlocks opportunity.

Geographic flexibility: Job markets vary dramatically by location. Remote options or relocation might open doors.

Industry pivot: Your skills might fit better in industries you haven't considered.

Being underemployed doesn't mean being stuck forever. But sometimes forward progress requires adjusting direction rather than pushing harder on the same path.

---

Ready to reframe your experience for better opportunities? ResumeFast's AI resume builder helps you highlight transferable skills and build compelling applications.